Non-Owner Car Insurance: Is It Worth the Investment?

If you drive cars that you don’t own, you might need non-owner car insurance to prove coverage in case of an accident. Although not owning a car can save you money by eliminating car payments and expensive repairs, you might still be responsible for insurance if you frequently rent or drive other people’s vehicles. In some cases, it may not be necessary to buy this type of insurance. 

For instance, if you borrow a vehicle from someone in your home, you might be listed on their car owner’s policy, depending on their insurer and the state laws. This can even apply if you’re borrowing from an unrelated roommate, and it’s possible to be covered even if you don’t have a valid license. But in situations where you’re not covered, non-owner car insurance provides an affordable option to stay protected.

According to a 2022 report by the Insurance Information Institute (III), approximately 5% of drivers in the U.S. opt for non-owner car insurance, particularly those who frequently rent cars or use car-sharing services.

Can You Get Insurance Without Owning a Car?

If you’re wondering whether you can get car insurance without owning a vehicle, the answer is yes. Non-owner car insurance provides liability coverage for individuals who don’t have their own vehicle but occasionally drive someone else’s. 

This type of coverage typically protects you from property damage and injuries you may cause to others in a car accident. However, it doesn’t cover any damage to the car you’re driving or pay for your own injuries if you cause the crash.

A non-owner policy offers only the minimum required coverage in your state, but you can often select higher limits for added protection. It may also include options like uninsured motorist protection and underinsured motorist protection, which provide coverage if you’re involved in an accident with a driver who doesn’t have enough or any liability car insurance. 

Additionally, some policies may include medical payments or personal injury protection, which help cover your injuries regardless of who is at fault. Unlike a standard auto policy, a non-owner car insurance plan doesn’t cover things like collision or comprehensive insurance, which are generally part of a regular policy. There’s typically no deductible on non-owner auto insurance, making it a more affordable option for those who need basic coverage while borrowing or renting a car.

Who Needs Non-Owner Car Insurance?

If you borrow someone else’s car often or rent vehicles on a regular basis, having a non-owner car insurance policy can save you from unexpected costs. Let’s dive into the key situations where this type of coverage is essential.

Frequent Borrowing of Other People’s Cars

When you borrow a friend’s car or use someone else’s vehicle, their insurance typically covers you in case of an accident. However, if the costs of the incident exceed the car owner’s liability limits, you might be stuck paying the remainder. 

For example, if you cause an accident and the other driver needs $35,000 worth of medical care, but your friend’s insurance only covers $25,000 in bodily injury liability coverage, you’ll be responsible for the remaining $10,000. This is where a non-owner policy can step in to cover that expense.

Case Study:

John, a 28-year-old freelancer, doesn’t own a car but frequently borrows his roommate’s vehicle for errands. When he caused a minor accident, his roommate’s insurance only covered 20,000 of the 30,000 in damages. Fortunately, John had a non-owner car insurance policy that covered the remaining $10,000, saving him from financial strain.

Renting Cars Frequently

If you rent cars frequently, a non-owner insurance policy can be a more affordable option than the rental company’s liability coverage. In addition to offering peace of mind, this policy ensures you’re protected in case of a rental car accident. While it won’t typically cover damage to the vehicle, you can purchase extra coverage like a collision-damage waiver from the rental car company or use your credit card to cover the damage.

A 2023 study by Statista revealed that over 40 million Americans rent cars annually, with many relying on non-owner car insurance to avoid costly rental company policies.

Case Study

Sarah, a travel blogger, rents cars at least twice a month. Instead of paying for the rental company’s expensive insurance, she opted for a non-owner car insurance policy. During one trip, she accidentally scratched the rental car. While the rental company charged her for the damage, her non-owner policy covered the liability costs for the other driver’s injuries.

Using Car-Sharing Services

With the rise of car-sharing services like Zipcar and Turo, drivers often believe they’re fully covered under the company’s insurance. However, these companies usually only provide coverage that meets your state’s minimum requirements. If you cause a bad wreck, the damage could easily exceed the state’s minimum limits, leaving you responsible for the excess costs. A non-owner policy can help supplement the coverage provided by these services.

Case Study

Mike, a college student, uses car-sharing services like Zipcar to get around campus. During one trip, he was involved in an accident that caused 15,000 in damages. While Zipcar’s insurance covered the state minimum, Mike’s non owner policy helped cover the remaining 5000, preventing him from paying out of pocket.

Driving a Company Car

When driving a company car, you may be covered under your employer’s auto policy for work-related tasks. However, personal use of the car, such as going to the store or running errands, may not be covered. If you don’t have personal use coverage under your company’s auto policy, a non-owner car insurance policy can cover you for any injuries, damage, or property you cause while behind the wheel.

Need for an SR-22 or FR-44 Form

In certain situations, such as after a DUI conviction, you may need an SR-22 or FR-44 form to reinstate your driver’s license. Insurers will file these forms for you to prove you have the minimum required insurance coverage as mandated by your state.

In states like Florida and Virginia, where FR-44 forms are required for high-risk drivers, the cost of non-owner car insurance can increase by 20-30% due to the added risk.

Case Study

After a DUI conviction, Emily needed an SR-22 form to reinstate her license. She purchased a non-owner car insurance policy, which not only fulfilled the SR-22 requirement but also provided liability coverage when she occasionally drove her friend’s car.

Maintaining Continuous Coverage

Even if you don’t own a car, it’s important to maintain continuous auto insurance. Going without coverage, even for a short period, can make you look risky to insurers, leading to higher rates when you decide to purchase insurance in the future. In these cases, it’s often more affordable to get non-owner insurance than to go without coverage entirely.

Read More: Comprehensive vs Third Party Car Insurance: Which is Best for You?

Who Shouldn’t Buy Non-Owner Car Insurance

When thinking about non-owner insurance, you might wonder if it’s a good choice for you. However, there are certain scenarios where buying a non-owner insurance policy may not be your best bet. Here are some situations where you might not need to invest in it.

1. If You Borrow a Car from Someone in Your Household

If the vehicle you drive belongs to someone you live with, chances are you are already covered under their insurance policy. Many insurance companies will list every driving-age member of the household on their policy. If you are listed as a covered driver, you probably won’t need a separate non-owner insurance plan. However, always double-check to ensure you’re properly listed and covered before getting behind the wheel, as coverage can sometimes be denied if you aren’t on the policy.

2. If You Borrow the Same Car Regularly from Someone You Don’t Live With

For those who borrow a car from a neighbor or a friend frequently, you might already be covered under their insurance policy. Car insurers usually include anyone who regularly drives their vehicle in their policy, regardless of whether you live together or not. Whether you’re a nanny who drives a client’s car to run errands, or just borrowing your neighbor’s vehicle for short trips, it’s always wise to check with the car owner to confirm you’re covered under their policy. Even if you’re covered, you should ensure everything is safe and in order.

3. If You Drive Rarely or Not at All

If you only drive once in a while or only rent a car occasionally, non-owner insurance might not be worth the expense. In this case, buying insurance at the rental counter or relying on a friend’s insurance policy when borrowing a car could be a more affordable option. If you’re driving someone else’s vehicle for a one-time event, it’s important to make sure you’re covered before you start. If you have permission from a friend to drive their car and an accident happens, not all insurance companies will cover the damage unless you’re properly insured.

In such cases, taking the time to confirm you’re covered is the key to staying protected. When in doubt, always ask for confirmation from the car owner.

Read More: What Is Rental Reimbursement Auto Insurance?

How much is non-owner car insurance Costs?

When considering non-owner car insurance, it’s essential to understand that costs can vary significantly depending on factors like your driving record, age, and how often you plan to drive. Typically, the price for this type of coverage is less than what you would pay for the same level of liability coverage on a car you own. 

However, if you need to file an SR-22 or FR-44 form, costs could be much higher, as the insurer may consider these added risks. It’s worth noting that the price can fluctuate depending on these variables, so it’s essential to be aware of these factors before you commit to a policy. 

Once you no longer need these forms, your costs will likely decrease, making it more affordable in the long run. If you don’t need it anymore, you’ll only pay for the coverage you actually require. Depending on your specific circumstances, non-owner car insurance may be a less expensive and flexible option for those who don’t own a car but still need insurance for occasional driving.

The cost of non-owner car insurance differs across states on average. For instance, in California, the average annual premium is around 500 while in New York it can go up to 700. States with higher traffic density and accident rates tend to have higher premiums.

Pros and Cons of Non-Owner Car Insurance

Before purchasing non-owner car insurance, weigh the advantages and disadvantages:

Pros:

• Affordable Coverage: Typically cheaper than standard car insurance policies.
• Liability Protection: Covers damages or injuries you cause to others in an accident.
• Continuous Coverage: Helps avoid gaps in insurance history, which can lead to higher premiums in the future.
• Flexibility: Ideal for frequent renters, car-sharing users, or those who borrow cars often.
• SR-22/FR-44 Compliance: Fulfills legal requirements for high-risk drivers.

Cons:

• Limited Coverage: Doesn’t cover damage to the car you’re driving or your own injuries.
• No Comprehensive/Collision Coverage: Excludes theft, vandalism, or accidents where you’re at fault.
• Not for Regular Drivers: If you drive daily, a standard policy may be more cost-effective.
• Household Exclusions: May not cover you if you live with a car owner and have access to their vehicle.

State-Specific Requirements for Non-Owner Car Insurance

Non-owner car insurance requirements vary significantly by state, so it’s crucial to understand your local laws before purchasing a policy. Here’s a complete guide covering all the essential information:

1. Minimum Liability Coverage

Every state mandates minimum liability coverage for drivers, which includes bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident, and property damage. These limits determine how much your insurance will pay if you’re at fault in an accident. Below are examples of state-specific requirements:

Why It Matters: New York also requires Personal Injury Protection (PIP), which covers medical expenses regardless of fault.

California:

$15,000 per person for bodily injury.

$30,000 per accident for bodily injury.

$5,000 for property damage.

Why It Matters: If you cause an accident in California, your non-owner policy must cover at least these amounts.

Texas:

$30,000 per person for bodily injury.

$60,000 per accident for bodily injury.

$25,000 for property damage.

Why It Matters: Texas has higher minimums than many states, so non-owner policies here may cost more.

New York:

$25,000 per person for bodily injury.

$50,000 per accident for bodily injury.

$10,000 for property damage.

2. No-Fault States

In no-fault states, drivers are required to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) as part of their insurance policy. PIP ensures medical expenses and lost wages are covered for you and your passengers, irrespective of who is responsible for the accident. States with no-fault laws include:

• Florida:
  • Minimum PIP coverage: $10,000.
  • Why It Matters: Even with non-owner insurance, you must have PIP if you drive in Florida.
• Michigan:
  • Minimum PIP coverage: Unlimited (optional limits available).
  • Why It Matters: Michigan has some of the highest insurance requirements in the U.S., so non-owner policies here may be more expensive.
• Other No-Fault States: New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Minnesota, North Dakota, and Utah.

3. SR-22/FR-44 Requirements

If you’re considered a high-risk driver (e.g., due to a DUI, multiple traffic violations, or driving without insurance), some states may require you to file an SR-22 or FR-44 form to prove you have the minimum required insurance. Here’s what you need to know:

• SR-22:
  • Required in most states for high-risk drivers.
  • Example: In Illinois, an SR-22 is required for three years after a DUI conviction.
  • Why It Matters: Not all insurers offer SR-22 filings, so confirm this before purchasing a non-owner policy.
• FR-44:
  • Required in Virginia and Florida for drivers with serious offenses like DUIs.
  • Example: In Florida, FR-44 requires higher liability limits than the state minimums.
  • Why It Matters: FR-44 policies are more expensive due to the increased coverage requirements.

4. State-Specific Exceptions

Some states have unique rules regarding car insurance, which can impact non-owner policies:

• New Hampshire:
  • Car insurance is not mandatory, but you must prove financial responsibility if you cause an accident.
  • Why It Matters: Even though insurance isn’t required, a non-owner policy can help you meet financial responsibility requirements.
• Virginia:
  • Drivers can pay an uninsured motor vehicle fee instead of purchasing insurance, but this provides no coverage.
  • Why It Matters: If you drive in Virginia, a non-owner policy is a safer and more cost-effective option than paying the fee.
• Other Exceptions:
  • In Alaska, non-owner policies must include uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.
  • In Ohio, non-owner policies are not available if you have regular access to a household vehicle.

Why State-Specific Knowledge Matters

Understanding your state’s requirements is critical because:

It ensures you’re legally compliant while driving.
It helps you avoid fines, penalties, or license suspension.
It ensures you have adequate coverage in case of an accident.

Conclusion

Non-owner car insurance is a smart investment for those who frequently drive cars they don’t own, offering essential liability coverage and financial protection. Whether you rent cars, use car-sharing services, or borrow vehicles regularly, this policy ensures you’re covered in case of an accident.

However, if you rarely drive or are already covered under someone else’s policy, it may not be necessary. Before deciding, assess your driving habits, compare quotes, and consult with an insurance expert. With the right coverage, you can drive with confidence and peace of mind. Ready to explore your options? Reach out to a trusted insurer today!

FAQs